how to prevent never events in hospitals
- National Partnership for Women & Families President Debra L. Ness. Often called Never Events, these include errors such as surgery performed on the wrong body part or on the wrong patient, leaving a foreign object inside a patient after surgery, or discharging an infant to the wrong person. "Never Events are a symptom of a health care system that is broken and unresponsive." 
Toward that end, we produce metrics on a quarterly basis concerning how frequently we saw care issues or improvement opportunities. As a result of the Medicare Modernization Act and the Deficit Reduction Act, hospitals that publicly report these quality measures receive higher Medicare payment updates. We are now mostly dealing with minute details, not gross errors. A 2013 study estimated that more than 4000 surgical never events occur yearly in the United States. In fact, in Minnesota, where reporting of never events is required, there has been little change in the frequency over the past decade. Jason Tross, Deputy Director. In the second year, 47 hospitals reported 106 events that resulted in 12 deaths and nine serious injuries. An official website of This is a meaningful way to measure progress in patient safety, because it measures something we feel we can influence i.e., how reliably we follow our best practices to prevent harm. Us. So we looked for additional improvement opportunities. NQFs full list is included in Appendix 2. 358 0 obj
<>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<7E2F043127C91C4AA3ADC0A1325BFC0B><779FA94D1D86AB41B98A685B5362275C>]/Index[342 26]/Info 341 0 R/Length 90/Prev 1503128/Root 343 0 R/Size 368/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream
Important for public credibility or public accountability. But rather than focusing on never events or sentinel events alone, we have chosen to look much farther. Since February 2009, CMS has not paid for any costs associated with wrong-site surgeries. Most Never Events are very rare. Thanks to the use of checklists and a bar-coding system to help count the sponges, we now have fewer than 5 per 1 million procedures (5.9 sigma). A number of techniques and process-improvement tools from inside and outside the industry have been brought to bear: lean engineering to simplify and standardize care, Crew Resource Management to improve teamwork, checklists to help teams focus and improve reliability, and so on. *jH"O_0^
@d!yr?&BqqpO3v!u)~ 3[CpX}[&SmmLhY(t. &
Care involves more team members, a faster pace, higher caseloads, and higher stakes. Consequently, working with provider associations and other public and private groups, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services is taking further steps to prevent never events.. CMS will also work with Congress on further legislative steps to reduce or eliminate these payments.
Misuse or malfunction of device (4 events). That same year, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services came out with a public statement on Never Events,in which it announced its intention to work with Congress, hospitals, and other health care organizations to reduce payments for Never Events and to provide more information to the public about when they occur. Because Never Events are devastating and preventable, health care organizations are under increasing pressure to eliminate them completely. The main reason is weve picked the low-hanging fruit. The Leapfrog Group today announced a partnership with Money.com to power Moneys lists of best hospitals and ambulatory surgery centers in the U.S. The Leapfrog Group All rights reserved. The Leapfrog Group is a nonprofit watchdog organization that serves as a voice for health care consumers and purchasers, using their collective influence to foster positive change in U.S. health care. Death or disability associated with hypoglycemia (1 event). These usually occur when the communication channel is unclear: e.g., when procedures are scheduled by someone other than the person who actually performs the procedure, or when there are changes in the patients condition or needs between the decision for and performance of the procedure. To continue to make progress and completely eliminate never events, we need new approaches, some of which will require new investment in tools, care environment, and our caregivers. The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely. Since the NQF disseminated its original Never Events list in 2002, 11 stateshave mandated reporting of these incidents whenever they occur, and an additional 16 states mandate reporting of serious adverse events (including many of the NQF Never Events). A follow-up report on preventing suicide: focus on medical/surgical units and the emergency department. Examples of never events include surgery on the wrong body part; foreign body left in a patient after surgery; mismatched blood transfusion; major medication error; severe pressure ulcer acquired in the hospital; and preventable post-operative deaths. The definition of never events in the numerator has changed over time. The term "Never Event" was first introduced in 2001 by Ken Kizer, MD, former CEO of the National Quality Forum (NQF), in reference to particularly shocking medical errorssuch as wrong-site surgerythat should never occur. 5600 Fishers Lane To sign up for updates or to access your subscriber preferences, please enter your email address Some states have enacted legislation requiring reporting of incidents on the NQF list. Patients feel the most anger when they perceive that no one is willing to take responsibility for the adverse event that has occurred. Tell us what health-care content youd like to see more of from HBR. We look for trends in opportunities in order to prioritize improvement work across our hospitals. Since then, many states and private insurers have adopted similar policies. We are now striving to deploy advanced display systems for all patient rooms. Death or disability associated with restraints (1 event). ;fbC/F(J3|9XfG ` 2qd1[n^k?Z_2d?{)rz$@yUZ(Q1` D)tPBjLz]X+Lzj&9)WT8G#Z b&q7E"]636@&e;t8Ba[O,TWV4# \g-s~.ib>5By &y{&{&T,{"=Q/s|~b:uZJULQhbBO:KZ*fW0"&I#-0 ae28kA|>^4n! +Qy)z2&3-p< +u Q.v090 CqC7rAz"'0 ]4\9,~}7HRGX (DxJ/~h^faCztRbnfe-MUI0P` ~ z@5`+3i> G-1^-a Z.en\gmFYT>^$|Dhg76(e8 xSW88 Contaminated drugs, devices or biologics (1 event), Sexual assault of a patient (2 events), and. Leapfrog is the nations premier advocate of transparency in health carecollecting, analyzing and disseminating data to inform value-based purchasing and improved decision-making. By acting in this way, we have reduced our surgical and procedural never-event frequency to less than 0.030 per 1,000 patient days (5.51 sigma), our advanced pressure ulcer rate to 1/60th the national average, and our overall never-event frequency to 5.24 sigma. In particular, CMS is reviewing its administrative authority to reduce payments for never events, and to provide more reliable information to the public about when they occur. From its beginning, the Medicare program has generally paid for services under fee-for-service payment systems, without regard to quality, outcomes, or overall costs of care. (Since clinicians judged that it was not causing harm and retrieving it might, they left it in.) We studied the root causes for over 60 surgical near-miss and safety events and found that cognitive factors such as channeled attention on a single issue, overconfidence or confirmation bias, inadequate vigilance, errors made based on inaccurate information, and distractions underlay many of them. '/OO~Cy"em~][BuE. The wrong type of procedure is no longer an appendectomy when a cholecystectomy was planned; rather it is insertion of one type of central catheter instead of one that was marginally different than the intended one, or it is the unintentional biopsy taken when only a diagnostic procedure was ordered. EIN: 52-2359517, Health Care Transparency, Safety and Quality in Your Inbox, Money today announced its inaugural list of the Best Hospitals in America, in partnership with The Leapfrog Group. In addition, the Minnesota Department of Health publishes an annual report and provides a forum for hospitals to share reported information across the state and to learn from one another. Since Leapfrog declared these principles as our standard, new research and experience have further informed evidence on best practices for addressing never events. Why? A more detailed listing of the most recent Minnesota findings is attached as Appendix 3. The Leapfrog Group recommends that in addition to an RCA, organizations should disclose the error and apologize to the patient, report the event, and waive all costs associated with the event. Consequently, even though some measures suggest there has been little change in the frequency of never events or other hospital-acquired conditions over time, many providers feel that their hospital care is much safer today than two decades ago. Search All AHRQ CMS is interested in working with our partners and Congress to build on this initial step to more broadly address the persistence of never events.. ;Du-P Learn more information here. For example, to ensure that the correct medicine is administered to the correct patient at the correct time, all 22 Mayo Clinic hospitals have done three things: Thanks to these measures, there have been no harmful incidents due to medication errors at our largest campus (in Rochester, Minnesota) for the past 13 months, and the combined rate of harm from medication errors at all 22 Mayo hospitals during the same period has averaged less than 0.021 per 1,000 patient days. Many hospitals already have a suitable policy in place. lD--|zhal hv4r}nGxK.Z;y)F`BO:UdWUj4=hklM.:/x4cH+|dP5tHib!~f(:KP~2_e8+U Br cagB>`r1rkuRgp(4)j-./TeRW. This includes the efforts of the Hospital Quality Alliance, which has developed an expanding set of quality measures. But asincere apology from the responsible hospital staff can help to heal the breach of trust between doctor/hospital and patient. For example, in 2003, the Minnesota legislature, with strong support from the state hospital association, was the first to pass a statute requiring mandatory reporting of never events. Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Clearly, paying for never events is not consistent with the goals of these Medicare payment reforms. Foreign objects left in patients after surgery (26 events).
Sign up to get the latest information about your choice of CMS topics in your inbox. For example, to tackle fall prevention, one of the most costly events in terms of both human suffering and financial impact, we need to invest in a redesign of hospital rooms. When such a deviation happens, we count those incidents as preventable harm events. These could be significantly reduced by development of an embedded information system a bar code of sorts that would register all of the requisite information wherever patients went in their care journey. Catherine Howden, Director The entire context of care has changed: Many of the current procedures, operations, and treatments were not performed a decade ago. @AVfS?l}: >LFKcDwX7"k.&PF_rU6^=&dv> The Deficit Reduction Act represents a first step in this direction, allowing CMS, beginning in FY 2008, to begin to adjust payments for hospital-acquired infections. endstream endobj startxref 367 0 obj <>stream Ironically, research indicates that malpractice suits are often the result of a failure on the hospitals part to communicate openly with the patient and apologize for its error. hbbd```b`` "fHd "Yu`)09,2f"k&(H( >&F`"30 ` 0* 47c7VVGsl7;yblOz^5/Wq]0:l,?V9^`n0 8werS:gdF!Q+*Slq!Q)'bGnWj5a%k,x@"A&du&ZJ;6f{;I[SiJ;;qr'9F=Gi];H\VP&0(EiKG,#:W5Hq;^.g'D%2gB]Is$ :n(RL~5}A?rmt16cB)Rq3~U4 pd\e'o%";(jypk4MC~_?23dh7;>#! [Available at]. To be included on NQFs list of never events, an event had to have been characterized as: CURRENT NATIONAL QUALITY FORUM LIST OF NEVER EVENTS, Any incident in which a line designated for oxygen or other gas to be delivered to a patient contains the wrong gas or is contaminated by toxic substances, RESULTS OF MINNESOTA S SECOND YEAR NEVER EVENT REPORTING. Death or injury of patient or staff from physical assault (1 event).
Eliminating Serious, Preventable, and Costly Medical Errors - Never Events. Several other states have considered or are currently considering never event reporting laws. Sentinel events are defined as "an unexpected occurrence involving death or serious physiological or psychological injury, or the risk thereof." But there are some errors so egregious that they should never happen to a patient under any circumstance. As part of its ongoing effort to pay for better care, not just more services and higher costs, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) today announced that it is investigating ways that Medicare can help to reduce or eliminate the occurrence of never events serious and costly errors in the provision of health care services that should never happen.
